The UN Security Council and Iraq’s Disputed Internal Boundaries

Document Type: Original Article

Author

Associate Professor of International Law, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamadan, Iran

Abstract

The UN Security Council initially used the phrase ‘disputed internal boundaries’ in an operative part of Resolution 1770 (2007) and then reiterated it in preamble paragraphs of Resolutions 1883 (2009), 1936 (2010), 2001 (2011), 2061 (2012), 2110 (2013), 2169 (2014), 2233 (2015), 2299 (2016), 2367 (2017) and 2421 (2018). That was the first instance in the history the UNSC to use such phrase. This article tries to survey and analyze this unusual phrase in these resolutions and it`s legal repercussions in the light of Iraq’s constitution as well as the political situation there. It seems that the 15-member Council has repeatedly endorsed the obligation of Baghdad and the Kurdish Regional Government to resolve their outstanding disputes including internal boundaries based on the national constitution especially Article 140. According to the Security Council, there exists a critical link between maintaining peace and security and the peaceful settlement of disputes in Iraq.
 

Keywords


  1. A: books and Articles
  2. Anderson Liam and Gareth Stansfield, Crisis in Kirkuk: The Ethno politics of Conflict and Compromise, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2009.
  3. Bartu Peter “Wrestling with the Integrity of a Nation: The Disputed Internal Boundaries of Iraq” (2010), International Affairs,Vol. 86 No. 6
  4. Frouville de Olivier , , “ On the Theory of the International Constitution” , in Denis ALLAND, Vincent CHETAIL, Olivier de FROUVILLE & Jorge E. VINUALES,eds.,  Unity and Diversity of International Law, Essays in Honour of Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy, ( Boston:MartinusNijhoff Publisher, 2014).
  5. Higgins Rosalyn, “ The Advisory Opinion on Namibia: Which UN Resolutions Are Binding under Article 25 of the Charter?”,( 1972 ), The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol. 21, No. 2,pp. 270-286
  6. Kane Sean, Iraq`s Disputed Territories: a view of the Political Horizon and Implications for U.S. Policy, United States Institute of Peace,2011
  7. Morris Samuel, KhogirWirya, DlawerAla’Aldeen, The Future of Kirkuk :A Roadmap for Resolving the Status of the Governorate, The Middle East Research Institute, September 2015.
  8. Öberg Marko Divac , ‘The Legal Effects of Resolutions of the UN Security Council and General Assembly in the Jurisprudence of the ICJ “, ( 2006 ), The European Journal of International Law, Vol.16, No.5, pp.879-906.
  9. Ramcharan G. Bertrand, The Security Council and the Protection of Human Rights, ( Hague: MartinusNijhoff Publisher, 2002).
  10. Mills Robin, Under the Mountains: Kurdish Oil and Regional Politics ,The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, University of Oxford,  January 2016
  11. Simma Bruno, Daniel ERASMUS KHAN, Georg NOLTE and Andreas PAULUS,eds., The Charter of the United Nations, ( Oxford University Press, 2012).
  12. Wollf Stefan, “Governing (in) Kirkuk: resolving the status of a disputed territory in post-America Iraq”, ( 2010), International Affairs,vol. 86, No. 6.
  13. Wood C. Michael, ,” The Interpretation of Security Council  Resolutions”, Max Plank Yearbook of United Nations Law,( 2007), Volume 11, pp.73- 95.
 

B: Case law and Reports

  1. Effects of Awards of Compensation made by the United Nations Administrative Tribunal. Advisory Opinion, {1954} I.C.J.
  2. Legal Consequences for States of the Continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South West Africa) Notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276 (1970), Advisory Opinion {1971} I.C.J.
  3. Western Sahara, Advisory Opinion {1975} I.C.J.
  4. Accordance with International Law of the Unilateral Declaration of Independence in Respect of Kosovo, Advisory Opinion {2010} I.C.J.
  5. The Legal Issues Involved In The Western Sahara Dispute The Principle of Self-Determination and the Legal Claims of Morocco, Committee on the United Nations, , New York City Bar,2012
  6. Kirkuk Status Referendum Operational Concept’, The Center for Democracy and Civil Society at Georgetown University, (2013), http://ckro. georgetown.edu/resources/framework.
  7. Report of the Secretary-General pursuant to resolution 2299 (2016) , S/2017/357 , 25 April 2017.
  8. United Nations Security Council Resolution 688 (1991) on the situation in Iraq, 5th April 1991 (UN Doc S/RES/688 (1991)), OXIO 174. See: Oxford Public International Law (http://opil.ouplaw.com). (c) Oxford University Press, 2015.
  9. S/RES/2325 (15 December 2016).
  10. S/RES/2378 (20 September 2017).
  11. S/RES/2396 (21 December 2017).