Comparative Analysis of UNESCO’s Approach and Performance towards the Cultural Heritage of Syria and Iraq (2003-2016)

Document Type: Original Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Faculty member of School of International Relations of Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Tehran, Iran

2 Master of International Relations and Diplomacy, School of International Relations of Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

This article seeks to analyze and explain the UNESCO’s procedures for the protection of cultural heritage in Syria and Iraq through comparative method and use of library resources. Cultural heritage in these countries has been always prone to destruction and theft due to armed conflicts. The terrorist groups in Syria and Iraq seek to eradicate the culture and identity of these two countries through destruction of cultural heritage (cultural cleansing) or illicit trade of cultural heritage. UNESCO has focused on combating cultural crimes within a special procedure, known as “Cultural Heritage Regime”, in order to protect the cultural heritage. According to the analysis of the present paper, UNESCO has failed to prevent the destruction of the cultural heritage in Syria and Iraq. However, this organization has been successful in reconstructing cultural heritage of Syria and Iraq. It also has acted successfully in cooperating with relevant institutions in order to confront with cultural crimes. Having regard to the UNESCO’s legal procedure, most of the rules applied to the status of cultural heritage in Syria and Iraq are related to the international rules for the protection of cultural heritage during armed conflicts, which include the UNESCO’s 1954 Convention for the Protection of Cultural Heritage in the Event of Armed Conflict and its protocols, as well as customary international humanitarian law. Regarding the declarative procedure, UNESCO has played an important role in alerting the international public opinion in order to protect the cultural heritage in Syria and Iraq.

Keywords


References

A)    Books and Articles

  1. A. P. V. ROGERS, Paul MALHERBE, Fight it right, model manual on the law of armed conflict for armed forces[Persian], (Tehran: Amir Kabir Publication, 2009).
  2. DJ, PUCHALA, Raymond F HOPKINS, “International Regimes: Lessons from Inductive Analysis”, (1982) International Organization, Vol. 36, No. 2 at 61-62.
  3. Diana ZACHARIAS, “The UNESCO Regime for the Protection of World Heritage as Prototype of and Autonomy-Gaining International Institution”, (2008) German Law Journal, Vol. 9, No. 11 at 6-7.
  4. Eyal BENVENISTY, The International law of occupation, (Princeton University press, 1992).
  5. Fazl-e-lah FORUGHI, Keyvan GHANI, “War Crimes against cultural heritage in armed conflicts of Syria” [Persian], (2014) Criminal Law and Criminology Studies, number 5 & 6.
  6. Farhad GHASEMI, Introduction to International Relations[Persian], (Tehran: Mizan Publication, 2012).
  7. Global Strategy on Organized and Emerging Crime, INTERPOL, Available at: https://www.interpol.int/en/Crimes/Organized-crime
  8. Jamshid MOMTAZ,International Humanitarian Law and non-international armed conflicts[Persian], (Tehran: Mizan Publication, 2006), at 59.
  9. J. LEPGOLD, M. NINCIC, Beyond The Ivory Tower: International Relations Theory and the Issue of Policy Relevance, (New York: Columbia University Press, 2001) at 113.
  10. John M RUSSELL, “A Personal Account of the first UNESCO Cultural Heritage Mission to Baghdad”, (2003) Publication and New Media.
  11. Joseph GRIECO, Introduction to International Relations: Enduring Questions and Contemporary Perspectives, 1st ed. (Red Globe Press, 2014) at 117.
  12. Mohammad HASSAN KHANI, Role of culture and cultural tools in designing and advancement of diplomacy; with a view on Foreign Policy of United States[Persian], (Tehran: Proceedings of Conference on Relation Between Culture and Politics, 2008).
  13. Priscilla SINGER, “The New American Approach to Cultural Heritage Protection: Granting Foreign Aid for Iraqi Cultural Heritage”, (2010) Topic for Cultural Heritage Law.
  14. Reza HAGHIGHI, Culture and Diplomacy[Persian], (Tehran: al-Mahdi Publication, 2008), at 2.
  15. Reza MOUSAZADEH, International Organizations[Persian], (Tehran: Mizan Legal Foundation, 2014), at 240.
  16. Robert O. KEOHANE, International Institutions and State Power, (Boulder, Colo, West View Press, 1989) at 27.
  17. Roger O’KEEFE, Camille PERON, Tofig MUSAYEV, Giabluca FERRARI, Protection of Cultural Property: Military Manual, (Paris, UNESCO, 2016).
  18. Susan CHERAGHCHI, “Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage”[Persian] (2005) Asar publication, Number 36, 37 at 245.
  19. Seyed Hesasm al-Din LESANI, “Protection of historic and cultural heritage by international law during the military occupation with a view on the Unites States responsibilities during military occupation of Iraq”, (2015).
  20. Sara RASOULI, “Difficulty of determining Jurisdiction of International Criminal Tribunal regarding the foreign fighters of ISIS (Daesh)”[Persian], (2017) Tahghighat-e Jadid dar Olum-e Ensani, No. 19 at 112.
  21. Seyed Reza SALEHI AMIRI, Saeed MOHAMMADI, Cultural Diplomacy[Persian], (Tehran: Ghoughnos Publication, 2014).
  22. Stacy BOLDRICK, Striking Images, Iconoclasms Past and Present, (London, Routledge, 2013), at 1.
  23. Sabine VON SCHORLEMER, Cultural Heritage Law: Recent Developments of the Laws of War and Occupation, (Paris, UNESCO, 2007) at 22.
  24. Timan RODENHAUSER, “International Legal Obligation of Armed Opposision Group in Syria”, (2015) International Review of Law.
  25. Yoram, DINSTEIN, The International Law of Belligerent Occupation, (Cambridge University Press, 2009).
  26. Yaron GOTTLIEB, “Criminalizing Destruction of Cultural Property: A Proposal for Defining New Crimes Under the Rome Statute of the ICC”, (2005) Penn State International Law Review, Vol. 23, Article 16 at 888.
 

B)    Treaties and UN Documents

  1. Additional Protocol to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and Relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts, 8 June 1977, ICRC, art 85: 2.
  2. Convention for The Protection of Cultural Property in The Event of Armed Conflict, 14 Mars 1954, Protocol 2, UNESCO, art 85: 4.
  3. Convention Concerning The Protection of The World Cultural and Natural Heritage, 16 November 1972, UNESCO, art 1.
  4. Reinforcement of UNESCO’s Action for The Protection of Culture and The Promotion of Cultural Pluralism in The Event of Armed Conflict, General Conference, UNESCO doc. 38c/49 (2015).
  5. United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime, United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, UN Doc. (2000).
  6. United Nation Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime and The Protocols Thereto, 15 November 2000, GA Res. 55/25, UN Doc, art. 2.